Why Exercise Alone Might Not Keep You Losing Weight
Share
If you have ever started an exercise routine and noticed that your weight dropped at first but then stopped changing, you are not alone. Many people experience this frustrating “weight loss plateau.” Even when you keep working out and eating about the same, the scale often refuses to move. Recent research by Lewis Halsey (2025) helps explain why this happens and it’s not just about willpower or hunger. It’s about something called energy expenditure compensation.
The Body’s Balancing Act
Our bodies are clever. When you start exercising more, you burn more calories. But over time, your body tries to balance things out by saving energy elsewhere. This process is known as energy expenditure compensation. It means your total daily calorie burn doesn’t rise as much as expected, even if you’re doing a lot of exercise.
For example, people who add workouts to their routine may start moving less during the rest of the day sitting more, fidgeting less, or doing daily tasks more slowly. The body might also become more efficient at exercise, meaning it burns fewer calories for the same activity. On top of that, other body systems like immune function or hormone production may slightly reduce their energy use. All these small changes add up and make your overall calorie burn level off.
What the Research Shows
Studies have repeatedly shown this effect. In one long-term trial, participants exercised five times a week for over a year. Despite burning hundreds of calories in each session, their weight loss stopped after a few months. Interestingly, they didn’t eat much more food, so the plateau wasn’t due to overeating.
In another study, people burned about 230 extra calories per day through exercise but only ate about 120 more. Yet, their total weight loss still slowed down. This shows that even when food intake is controlled, energy expenditure can adjust downward, limiting progress.
Even among highly active populations like the Hadza hunter-gatherers of Tanzania, who walk miles every day, total daily energy expenditure is surprisingly similar to that of sedentary Westerners. The human body seems to have a built-in limit to how many calories it will burn each day, no matter how active we are.
Why This Matters for Weight Loss
This doesn’t mean exercise is useless. It’s incredibly important for heart health, muscle strength, mental wellbeing, and longevity. But if your main goal is to lose weight, you need to understand that exercise alone may not keep producing steady results.
When the body adapts to regular workouts, it tries to save energy in other ways. This means the calorie deficit you had in the beginning gets smaller over time, slowing or even stopping weight loss.
How to Break Through a Plateau
If you hit a weight loss plateau, it doesn’t mean you’ve failed. It simply means your body has adapted. Here are a few ways to respond:
1. Mix up your training.
Change your workout type, intensity, or duration. Adding intervals or resistance training can challenge your body in new ways and may help increase total energy use.
2. Add non-exercise movement.
Small movements throughout the day walking, standing, or light chores can help counteract the body’s tendency to conserve energy.
3. Watch your food intake.
Even small increases in snacking or portion sizes can cancel out the calorie deficit. Track what you eat for a week to see if there are unnoticed changes.
4. Try cycle-based approaches.
Some experts suggest alternating periods of higher exercise with periods of reduced exercise and controlled eating. This may help prevent the body from fully adapting and compensating.
5. Focus on progress beyond the scale.
Improved fitness, strength, and mood are all signs that your body is benefiting, even if your weight doesn’t change much.
The Takeaway
Weight loss is more complex than “calories in versus calories out.” The body’s natural ability to adjust energy use is a powerful survival mechanism but it can make modern weight loss tricky. Understanding energy expenditure compensation can help set more realistic expectations and guide smarter strategies.
In short, if your progress slows, your body isn’t broken, it’s adapting. Keep moving, keep experimenting, and remember that the goal isn’t just a number on the scale, but a healthier, stronger you.
